Matt Casarino

I am one-half of Hot Breakfast!, Delaware's Premier Acoustic Dork-Rock Power Duo. The other half is Jill Knapp, who is the most wonderful thing on the planet.

  • Followed
  • Follows you

Edit biography

There are very few phrases more reviled, and defended, than "trigger warning."

And without making it a thing (because that's not what this post is about), I see both sides of the argument. Yes, most of us did survive not only years of higher learning but decades of internet-plundering-and-discovery without the need to be "warned" that a piece of reading or information might "trigger" us to recall, or even relive, a past trauma. And trying to predict what those triggers might be is a terribly daunting task; ya never know, in other words, what might set somebody off. But for Jared Leto's sake, what is the harm of warning somebody that material potentially perilous for those who have suffered trauma or even PTSD lies ahead? Sure, we didn't do this in the past, but we also wore wool in the summer and enslaved people in the past*. What is the harm of briefly warning readers that the following material discusses subjects that some might find disturbing on a personal level?

So that's my position - I won't judge anyone for using trigger warnings, and I won't judge if you don't. But again, that's not really what this post is about. It's about my recent experience being "triggered," and what it says about my specific anxiety issues.

I've written about anxiety and panic a few times on OPW, and I'm grateful for the opportunity. It's a tricky subject for me - I love having a semi-public outlet in which to share some of my experiences with panic attacks, but I'm painfully aware "anxiety" is becoming, to many, one of those buzzwords that, like "chronic lyme," "chronic fatigue," and "fibromylagia," causes certain eyes to roll. After all, there's no test for anxiety, and like "chronic lyme," anxiety produces no antibodies; when someone says they have debilitating anxiety, we pretty much have to take them at their word. Lately I'm becoming hyperaware that, while few people doubt anxiety attacks exist, some are starting to think it's one of those too-easy diagnoses people give themselves to explain, or allow, the little breakdowns that come when life is a bit overwhelming. And geez, who among us hasn't been overwhelmed?

(NOTE: I embedded a video from SNL above. But it might not show up on a mobile phone - if not, click here.)

Funny bit, yes? I laughed at a lot of it - even the barely audible sigh of contempt from the narrator as he claims the high-maintenance girl "quote has...anxiety." Yep, I laughed - right through the pit in my stomach. 

I know it happens. I know some people raise their eyebrows at the idea that "anxiety" is really anything more than the feeling they get before a test, or a job interview, or taking a tricky pool shot with $5 on the line. To them, it's a 21st-century excuse, a make-believe affliction. "We all have anxiety sometimes," they say. "Some of us just know how to deal with it."

Or that's what they wanna say, anyway.

Look, I get it. I do. If I didn't know first-hand what it feels like when your fight-or-flight mechanism goes on overload, how it compromises my hearing and balance, how my muscles shake uncontrollably while a very strange kind of fear grips my throat, how my heart rate increases and, more alarming, feels like my heart is pushing against my ribcage, how tears stream down my cheeks like they need to escape my eyes - and how all of that happens while I remain aware (on some level) that I'm actually fine, nothing is wrong, no one is trying to hurt me - maybe I'd suspect sufferers of anxiety are making mountains out of molehills, or wanting the kind of attention that comes with affliction. There have been a few instances (see: above buzzwords) when I've thought specific people were (are), at best, mistaking - perhaps deliberately - their conversion disorder or muscle pain for an invasive disease. 

But, of course, this attitude doesn't help. As a good friend told me recently, "keeping it to yourself because you're afraid of the eye-rolls behind your back is a great path to depression and agoraphobia." So that's partially why you're lucky enough to be reading this post. :) Because I suspect all of the above factors into why I was triggered into a pretty severe bout of anxiety while in the safest place I know from the description of a years-old online video: 

Reporter Discusses How an On-Air Panic Attack Improved His Life

I didn't see the video. Heck, I didn't even see the headline: Jill did, and she thought it was an important video for her to watch. She asked me if I wanted to, and I declined - I figured I might find it upsetting. 

What I didn't realize is I was already upset. And my attack had already started the moment she read those words aloud.

The idea of the guy having a public attack while simply doing his job was my trigger. I only heard a few words from the video - the anchor (not the reporter) was simply introducing the story - when I realized I was in trouble. I told Jill I would put on headphones so I couldn't hear the story. But Jill put her own headphones on instead - for about three seconds, when she looked at me and realized I was on my way. And even though she did everything right, I was in for a remarkably extended attack, complete with an eye-of-the-hurricane break in the middle, which I foolishly interpreted as a welcome ending. It was intense and exhausting enough that we had to cancel our social plans that evening - plans that actually included hanging out with our friend who said the wise words above.

So what did I learn from this? Well, for one, this highlighted something I knew but couldn't really articulate: "triggers" are more than the various words, entities, locations, and situations that tend to get the fight-or-flight instinct churning. They can be ideas, concepts that suggest my issues go beyond my general phobias (which include being stuck in a big, chaotic crowd and getting trapped with a tight shirt halfway over my head) and into darker fears about public humiliation that I can maybe focus on a little harder. Because even though Jill tells me the reporter's panic attack wasn't graphic - he recognized he was in the very early stages when he smiled and simply ended his segment early - the thought of going through something similar, of being exposed while working in front of an audience, is nightmarish in a way I can't really express. (Even writing that sentence churned up the anxiety machine. I had to step away. It's now many hours later.)

So am I suggesting triggers are...good? In a way, yes. They hold secrets. Before that night, I thought my triggers were based in the locations where I had the worst attacks - grocery stores, the Verizon place (something about rows and rows of product), crowds in which I'm adrift. But now I know that there's a certain primal fear that can send my adrenal medulla into interstellar overdrive. And while knowing is decidedly less than half the battle, it's an important step. For me, anyway. 
_ _ _ _ _ _ _

This has been another eposide of Matt's Brain is an Asshole. Stay tuned for many, many more episodes. If you'd like to contribute to my Patreon, hold that thought until I create a Patreon. 

* We haven't actually stopped enslaving people, but that's One Post for another day.

MORE
5/30 '17 9 Comments
Thanks for sharing this. I suspect that now that we're a little older, more and more of us have at least one "eye roller problem" ourselves and don't have any trouble at all accepting these explanations at face value.

Uhhh... Those of us with any degree of introspection, anyway.
I'm glad you said "at least". :)
I thought really hard for a moment but couldn't name a single person I know who thinks anxiety/panic attacks are some kind of make-believe thing. But I don't tend to hang out with the sort of people who would think that. So.

Myself, I never experienced anxiety with a capital "A" until I hit perimenopause. It happened to very roughly coincide with a couple of auto accidents I was in that happened in rapid succession, so there was the assumption that that was the ... genesis I guess? Anyway, not knowing what in the world was happening to me, once a knowledgeable friend suggested it might be panic attacks/anxiety, I RAPIDLY made phone calls to find a therapist. Busy moms of three can't afford to be paralyzed with debilitating symptoms.

Here's where it gets interesting. And why I've come to a couple of personal conclusions about it all. One, anxiety and panic are SO person-specific. The result is very much the same, but the genesis and ongoing struggle is a World of One for anyone dealing with it. And two, I think that—at root—we might be talking about a basic physiological event/process/cascade and while cognitive therapies can help one cope with the event, a more physiological approach to dealing with the problem would work better. At least, that was true in my case. (And someday I will come up with a perfect solution applicable to everyone and invite you to my Nobel acceptance ceremony.)

By physiological approach I'm not talking about meds here. I'm think about figuring out the wiring and the physical and chemical cascade and how to change that. Or at least endure it better.

What I did, as a long-time massage therapist, was to seek out a therapist who not only practiced SE but who *also* was a massage therapist. And we did all the SE stuff and it was marginally helpful, but finally I just said, "Look, can I just get on the table and have you work on me?" And that was the turning point. And then a year or two later, after we'd moved to Vermont and I was out trying to have a nice bike ride and not having it work (because elevating my heart rate above a certain point was inducing panic symptoms), I also recalled my own massage background and applied a breathing technique that I've used for decades and which is clinically proven to lower (among other things) cortisol levels. I started breathing that way basically all day every day for a week or so. And something about that process broke the cycle.

Since then, I've had comparatively mild episodes, and I can always link them to a combination of hormone shifts happening as a result of aging coupled with stress (of any sort that might raise cortisol levels). Always. And as my overall hormone levels even out and stop rising/falling/rising/falling/ad nauseum, so goes the frequency and strength of any anxiety.

Not sure why I'm sharing all of this, other than to say, "Go you!!" How wonderful have a useful epiphany around this stuff. Big steps, baby steps, 1/16th of the battle—who cares? It's just good to have an insight.
Thank you so much for sharing all of this! That's wonderful that you found...if not a cure, then some fantastic elixirs.

To be honest, I can't *NAME* a person who thinks anxiety is...um, I was about to say "all in my head." Let me rephrase. :) ...is an affliction being claimed by some people who just get a little overwhelmed from time to time. But "anxiety" is one of those words that make some eyebrows roll. "Oh, he has anxiety? Great. I get anxious sometimes too, sweetheart, but I can still have cold ones with the brahs."

Of course, when I put it that way, there's a damn good reason we can't name anybody like that...

Thank you again, I always love reading your insights - about this, and everything. A few techniques and meds have actually made these attacks a lot less common than they were at one point. Of course, my mind loves to whisper things like "c'mon, Casarino, you know they're just placebos, right? They're like Tinkerbell - they only work because you believe in them. The minute you stop clapping, they stop working."

Yeah - my mind is an asshole sometimes. Maybe I need to take my cue from another Simpson's episode and shove some crayons in my nose.
I totally get that. My brain is an uber asshole. I am the biggest science nerd anti-Tinkerbell body worker you will ever ever meet. I mean, if you ever actually do meet me. I have much seekrit disdain for Woo-Woo practitioners of every stripe. Show me the clinical data! Or talk with me about your years of experience with Technique X where it has worked over and over and over whether or not your client knew what you were doing or had any expectation of outcome.

In the absence of hard data I am quite happy to embrace mystery, but I want mystery with consistent results.
"...who thinks anxiety is...um, I was about to say "all in my head." Let me rephrase. :) ...is an affliction being claimed by some people who just get a little overwhelmed from time to time."

I wonder how much of the problem with 'eye rollers' is... laziness. I mean - look at how much effort you had to go through just to rework that phrase. If someone is too lazy to spend that kind of effort / time on actually discussing a problem with someone who faces it, I could see them taking a lot of 'shortcuts'. Like rolling their eyes rather than talk.

ETA: all of which is to say - I wouldn't worry too much about folks who are rolling their eyes. In my not so humble opinion - they've already let you know how much they're willing to invest in someone other than themselves.

May seem harsh, but I don't think it is any more so than they are to those with afflictions that they (the eye rollers) don't understand.
Gaaah! Thank you for mentioning this physiological link! I am convinced (and this is the ever-so-qualified Dr. Knapp with a music degree talking here) that Matt's root cause is *physical.* Like, he was fiiiiine for the 2 years when we first got together and for the prior 10 that we had been friends), and then when his gall-bladder went kablooey in 2013 they yanked it in an emergency surgery. The *very next day* he started having terrible GI problems that would leave him destroyed for 4-6 hours after, well, pooping. (Sorry babe.) And that went on for years, beyond any reasonable body-readjusting-to-no-gall-bladder period. And one day those post-poop episodes stopped cold, and that very day were replaced with crippling anxiety attacks. And on the rare day he didn't have an anxiety attack, he'd get a proctalgia fugax that would leave him in tremendous agony that nothing but time (hours!!) could help. Some days he gets both an anxiety attack and the butt-fugax. So try convincing me it ain't physical.

I will uneducately scream "Vagus nerve!" until I am dead. I so desperately want to be wrong.

When we've gone to doctors, we've gone to GI guys who stop listening at "gall bladder surgery" and prescribe bile salts. Or he's gone to his normally-super-awesome shrink who tells him "Go stand where you're sure to trigger an attack, and go have one in public and then you'll see it's not that bad to cry and shake and punch yourself and collapse in the Verizon store." (Sorry doc, gonna have to disagree with you here.) I want to scream. The love of my life, the center of my world, my perfect other half is hurting hurting hurting (and taking it like a champ!) and all I can do is watch the 3x/week torture. (Which I will take over 6x/week torture, but it's still torture.)

Sorry to vent. I would give a fucking kidney for an answer or a clue as to where to go next.
Oddly enough, I *just* this morning read a NYTimes article about a woman who had a couple years of crippling problems--GI, anxiety, headaches, I forget what else--and on a *whim* her doctor did some blood work to check thyroid levels and adrenaline levels. Thyroid, fine, adrenaline off the charts. Turned out to have a tumor on one of her adrenal glands.
I just read that! The one about the "pheo." My dear friend since middle school has it too, so I forwarded it along to him (though I'm sure it didn't tell him anything he didn't already know). But it made me feel like it's within the realm of possibility that Matt's affliction could be physical.

Xo!
 

In 2008 (and please correct me if I'm letting nostalgia color things with a warmer palate than deserved), those of us on the left were proud not just because we won after 12 years of conservatism, not just because we proved that when your candidate is brilliant, erudite, and - y'know, cool - he could win an election even if his skin tone was brown, his hair tight and curly, his name dangerously Middle Eastern, and his opponent a beloved, universally admired hero of war (with, granted, conveniently horrific taste in running mates). 

No, we were most proud of Obama's victory because we believed it was a victory for America. For all Americans. Yes, we were too quick to dismiss some of his detractors as unable to see past his skin color and background (while this was true of some, the generalization backfired greatly). But even to them, we said: look, this is the one. This guy is here for you, too. You don't have to worry. He's one of us, and he's going to make you better off too. Everybody chill the fuck out. He's got this.

Nobody is saying this about the new guy. 

Today, it's "better run, Muslims. Get outta town, illegals." And to liberals, those "snowflakes," they have one word:

                                                       Or is that two?

The happy people are at their happiest when they're rubbing it in the faces of the losers. That's right, go cry, losers! You sad, pathetic - when will the right figure out how idiotic they sound when they use "snowflake" as a pejorative? Geez, conservative Twitter has more snowflakes than Fargo. They have 80-gallon drums of "liberal tears" too, and...ah, you know the details. You've seen them. The variations are limited, to say the least.

Shortly after the election, a conservative (but staunchly anti-Trump) friend of mine contacted his liberal friends personally. He told them he knew they were upset, but he didn't want us to worry - he truly believed everything would be all right. Before you get angry at him for not getting past his white male privilege, at least join me in appreciating his intent. He knew we were hurting, and he wanted to help, even if he didn't know how. Even those of us who are LGBTQ, African American, Latinx, disabled, or otherwise in the crosshairs of the new administration appreciated his attempt at being a friend.

Thing is, it didn't last. His patience wore thin. He started lashing out at those who bemoaned the Electoral College, who took to the streets in protest, who refused to ever accept the winner as "my president." He started painting us all in the same strokes as the most radical, hateful "liberal" he could find - if some jerk wrote that he wished the new guy would have a heart attack, we all wished it. That sort of thing. He started taking delight in posting deliberately provocative missives and responding "get over it" (and "get used to it") when we protested. In short, he, like nearly every conservative on social media, enjoyed our loss far more than his victory. 

And so it goes. Snowflakes. Liberal tears.

Granted, some people really do want this particular guy in charge. Sure, some peeled off when the campaign promises that pushed them to vote 'R' vanished like rice paper in a volcano, but many cannot wait for the new rules, whatever they may be. Another faction doesn't want the new guy to succeed, exactly - what they want is to tear the whole thing down (riots, Martial Law, the works), forcing us into a governmental do-over that omits key phrases like "all men are created equal" and the 19th Amendment. Their guy won, too.

Look in the bios of these folks, and you see the same thing. They "drink liberal tears." (Another one.) They can't wait to restore law and order. Watch out, liberals and gays oh wait that's redundant (haw haw!). There aren't many variations on this, so it gets boring quickly - the only game is to see who is willing to use full-on racial, homophobic, misogynist slurs, and who isn't. (They're all willing to use offensive memes.) You lose, losers. All lives matter, but not yours.

The spirit of 2008 is gone. These folks aren't the least bit interested in communicating that the country is better off for everyone, that the new guy has good ideas for all of us, that we'll be okay and everything will be all right. 

Maybe they're just being honest. Maybe they know that while they'll be all right, we certainly will not be. Which means they really did win. And man, did we ever lose. 

MORE
1/20 '17 9 Comments
People were joyful in 2008 because we thought the world was moving forward, that progress was finally coming in this huge, tangible way and things would only get better, people would only be kinder to each other and more open and the world would stop looking at gender or sexual orientation or skin color and just see people.

It hurts so badly, so deeply to be wrong.
This exactly. Put much better than I could at the moment.
Too sad for words. Liberal with literal tears.
Yep.

And those, them, the guys and gals what did it, are a hefty majority of my ethnicity. The people who look like me, the people I went to school with, did this.

Even amongst women, a majority.
I extremely embarrassed, (This may not be the best word. Shocked?), at the amount of women who voted for him. It makes me really want to know what they were thinking (no sarcasm).
I posted this link in response to another of Matt's post, but probably it will get missed by most of the commenters here, since it's an older post. It's resonating strongly with me. It's a long read but worth it, as it tackles a unique way of framing "what happened" and "what people were thinking," but also goes beyond that to suggest ideas for framing our future success in regaining some power over the narrative, and why attempts to do that have so far failed.

https://georgelakoff.com/2016/11/22/a-minority-president-why-the-polls-failed-and-what-the-majority-can-do/
This article is absolutely AMAZING. I am only halfway through it but I'm hanging on every word. I had to stop reading just to thank you for posting it.

Really. Thank you!
You have nailed what bothers me most.
 

Lots of hubbub about Russia "hacking" or "rigging" our elections lately.

But those words aren't quite accurate, are they. Even if the allegations are correct, the Russians didn't alter the results, or install malware on our machines. (If they did, the only sane thing to do is a do-over, a heavily audited one on paper ballots.) It's more accurate to say the Russians "influenced" our voters, by publishing hacked DNC emails and creating false narratives about one of the contenders, among other tactics.

And while it's no trick to temporarily stir up infochaos, it really shouldn't stick. Not against an informed populace, anyway. Fortunately for Russia, they didn't choose an informed populace. They chose us.

If one thing has become clear to me, it's that Americans - on all sides - don't want information. Information is hard. It has no feelings. It holds our hearts up the the mirror and forces us to look, to reassess how we feel. We don't like that.

We want ammunition. We don't care if news is "fake" if it supports our narrative. We don't learn facts to challenge our bias and increase our knowledge base - we learn "factoids" we can trot out to make ourselves appear, and feel, "right." Even when we're wrong.

And we certainly don't mind being shown hard evidence that we were duped. If cognative dissonance doesn't kick in, allowing us to deny the reality we see before us, we'll simply blame our gullibility on the victim, claiming we were only duped because the person being smeared is so bad that the false bit could have been true. Rational people, of course, would wonder what other false narratives have skewed their perceptions. That ain't us - we give ourselves a hug and - to work a terribly overworked word even harder - double-down.

That's the American way. Whether or not it's a by-product of the Age of Internet is beside the point; it's our way of life now. And it has consequences.

Look, it makes sense for people to be angry when a guy cons them. But when they willingly hand him their wallets - and another $20 on top of that - you have to conclude that they want to be conned. They enjoy it.

And it isn't going to stop. 

A wise man once said "be it heaven or hell, the Christmas we get we deserve." Trust this guy - he was so wise he chose to die before his time rather than live one more second in this brave new world. (What a lucky man he was.)

MORE
12/13 '16 7 Comments
I've wanted to respond to this for a while but haven't been able to articulate quite what I'm thinking. But let me take a swing at it now.

I don't think Americans are averse to information. I think it would be more accurate to say that we're overwhelmed with it. Saturated so thoroughly that manipulation becomes a much easier game. Not only that, but the science of pyschometrics—at one time more of an Asimov's-Foundation-Series sci-fi notion but now a very real science, one augmented by powerful modern data computing systems—ensures that vast swaths of people exposed to propaganda will respond as desired. Which is a breathy way of saying, be careful not to blame the victim too much here.

While social structures and technology have gone through vast upheaval and change in the cosmological blink of an eye, humans have not had a similar rapid evolution. We're wired pretty much the same way we were 1,000 years ago, 10,000 years ago. HARD-wired anyway. And there's another problem--that current SOFT-wiring. Our grandparents cognitive exposure and our own and our children's exposure to technology has had profound effects, layered on top of a hardware system never designed or evolved to cope with such things.

It hardly surprises me that some of us monkeys have figured out ways to use the current set-up to their exclusive advantage. Nor is it surprising that such ancient instincts overlaid on modern times has/is/will cause no end of suffering and confusion.

But the technology (soft and hard) that is causing this mess is also the very same stuff that can rapidly advance solutions. While some of the monkeys are selfish, some act out ancient altruistic patterns, and all of this happens at a faster and faster rate.

Which is another breathy way of saying, "Don't give up on us quite yet." And maybe even, "Pay attention, and lend a hand when and how you can."
I'm so sorry it took me so long to read this! (Happy new year.)

You make an excellent point that media evolution has outpaced human evolution by a crazy-ass factor. I hadn't thought of it that way, but it's undeniably true. It's also pretty damned impressive, if I can pat the collective we on the back for a moment. But thank you so much for bringing all that up - you've given me a different perspective on the issue.

I mean, it was a cranky post. And I use "us" as a way of including myself in this mess. But you're right - I am indulging in some victim-blaming here. I know that's pretty obnoxious, but I decided several months ago (before the unfortunate phrase "fake news" became a thing) that the collective "we" are going to have to be the ones who take responsibility for our own info-filter. We can't count on our media sources, especially social media. Our worldview used to be shaped by our values + facts - but we now live in a world where we can find "facts" that support our worldview. We don't have to tolerate challenges. The internet should be a source of truth, but I think we are culpable for letting it be a source of comfort instead. I've been shouted down (to put it kindly) for putting actual data where it was clearly unwelcome. Just today, in fact, I let a conservative friend of mine (an 80-year-old gent, I love the lug) know that, in fact, Obama did not open the floodgates for, sigh, "illegals" to enter - that he's responsible for deporting more illegal immigrants than any president to date - so many that immigrant advocates call him "Deporter-in-Chief." I provided data - I even gave 'em a DT tweet in which he agreed to the very same thing. His, and his friends', response: "I'm going to choose to disbelieve these facts and go with my feelings."

So that's what I mean. If we aren't demanding to get to the bottom of this, we are to blame. I'm to blame, too - I gave up. But I'm going to stick with it. Maybe, when the gold-and-orange dust settles, we're all going to get a crash course in incredulity. If we accept it, maybe we'll be much better at this in a few years. But if we let ourselves be ruled by what we want to be true, rather than what is true, don't we deserve what we get?
Happy new year to you, too! Such as it is.

It's such an intractable problem, isn't it? How we pick and choose what to believe, what to discard.

And I'm as guilty as the next person for lounging back and stating problems but having little constructive input into *solutions.* Lately I've been passing around this article, which I think both speaks to what you and I are mulling over but also offers a way to chip away at what to do about it. It's a bit of a long read, but I'd love to know what you think.

https://georgelakoff.com/2016/11/22/a-minority-president-why-the-polls-failed-and-what-the-majority-can-do/
"We want ammunition. We don't care if news is "fake" if it supports our narrative. We don't learn facts to challenge our bias and increase our knowledge base - we learn "factoids" we can trot out to make ourselves appear, and feel, "right." Even when we're wrong."

I'm sad to say that I think you hit the nail on the head. The quoted paragraph is (in my personal experience) 95% of the issue. Even when I grit my teeth and tried to better understand 'the other side', all I received as a response was factoids, and I'm not a big enough man to keep from shutting down at that point.

Yes, I could have done more research (rather than personal interactions) but that sounds dangerously like making an effort.
Not just an American thing. Look at what's happening in Europe. Humans prefer stories to hard numbers.
Maybe, Tom, bit at least England has that "Vindaloo" song.
My lunatic tinfoil hat theory is that the White House needs to bring back Federal Project One, so nuts like me can get paid to spread stories.
 

So, panic attacks. I get 'em. They became a part of my life again a year ago, and I can expect one once every six weeks.

A Friday afternoon a few weeks ago, one arrived while I was in the Verizon store, staring at the wall of phone accessories while waiting to pick up my new phone. I was happy walking into the joint, for not only was I about to have a new toy, a glowing hand-held communication & porn machine, I was also about to spend the weekend looking after one of the best dogs in the world. I was in a happy place. But then - to make a long story short - I wasn't. 

We got outta there as soon as we could - i.e., once we got our damn phones - and I was able to mostly recover before our gig that night. (Yep, a gig. My timing sucks.) By Monday, my brain was back to normal (for me). Soon enough, it was time to return to the Verizon store.

And oh, shit.

Just thinking about the Verizon store, picturing that cursed wall of accessories while imagining facing the friendly but Sales-101 people, was giving me another fucking panic attack. And fuck. That. As I tried to calmly let Jill know the thought of returning to the store was getting to me, my voice cracked, everything went blurry, and once again, tension overrode reason.

I did two good things: I went to the store anyway for a successful purchase of phone cases, and soon as I could, I called my therapist. 

I can live with panic attacks. In fact, for a while, they're kind of neat. Sure, they eventually turn terrifying, and they sure are inconvenient. But every six weeks? That's not too bad. My life can accommodate that. 

But. An attack caused by considering returning to the location of the last attack? That there is some bullshit. And I'm not having it. So let's see what the good doctor can do.

Here, in the simplest, shortest way possible, is what said doctor told me:

  • Remember when I said panic attacks are kind of neat? (No? Geez, it was only, like, 80 words ago.) Well, what if I was able to think of them as neat while I was having them?
  • Panic is tension. By trying to calm down, you are pushing against your panic, and what do you create when you push against something? Tension. You feed the panic by fighting it, even by fighting with "peaceful" tools like meditation and grounding exercises.
  • I told my therapist I experience good anxiety and bad anxiety. The good, I explained, is the kind I feed on when I'm about to perform for people; I can turn it into focused energy and let it drive my performance. The bad, of course, is the stuff of attacks - chaotic and unfocused, it makes me feel out of control, sending me into a mess of emotions while making my body shake, sweat, and twitch uncontrollably.
    Doctor: "Matt, good anxiety and bad anxiety are exactly the same. There's only one kind. It's your perception that makes it good or bad."
    Me:  =0

I used to meditate, I found it a great exercise in both relaxation and humility, because as it turns out it's really fucking difficult to just sit and focus on your breathing without thinking. I think it's ultimately about acceptance - accepting who you are, where you are in the moment, what you're feeling, what you're thinking. I was thinking I should really get back to meditating when this happened:

"How about you have a panic attack now?"

Wait, what?

"What if I were to induce a panic attack right now? Then I can show you what I mean about accepting it."

I...uh...

"Actually, no, we're not going to do it now. I can see how much tension the idea is causing you. How about next week?"

If you're thinking "how is this guy going to induce a panic attack? Is there, like a brain button I don't know about?" then you and I were ridin' the same bus (except for that stuff about a "brain button." Where the hell did you get that? That's just silly. Brain button. Come on). But I was game, and willing to bypass my skepticism and work with him as best I could. I made my appointment. And when the day came, I wanted my attack. I doubted it would happen, of course. How could this guy - a guy I trust with my soul, a small, gentle, wonderful man, give me a panic attack?

He didn't He gave me two. 

They weren't complete - they didn't bloom into full-on, out-of-control anxiety - but if he hadn't stepped in to help me stop them, they both would have sent me spiraling into chaos. I'm still reeling from what happened.

The session went like this: I stood behind his desk, staring at his wall of bookshelves, while he stood next to me, blocking my only exit (the desk was against the wall). And while we stood, he asked me to imagine a hundred people in that room, watching us. He used some specifics to ramp up the urgency, and within 10 minutes, maybe 15, I was in the first stages on a full-on anxiety attack - losing touch with visual reality, as though one of my contact lenses was replaced with a tie-dye plastic film. Or...something, the visuals are hard to describe. But my breathing was shallow, my throat was so clenched it was hard to answer his questions, and my neck was on fire.

At that point, when I was on the verge of really crossing over, he asked me to give my body permission to feel what it was feeling. This required saying it, out loud, until I meant it. It really was okay for my neck to be glowing. It was okay for my breathing to puddle-deep, for my legs to feel rubbery, for my brain to be in a cloud. My body was just doing what it had to do, and it's okay. I give it full permission to do these things.

And once I started believing what I was saying, My tension level dropped 15%. A little later, I was taking full breaths, and I could move my legs without effort. 

Neat, huh? But I'm not quite done, and this next part is really important. I'm trying to be concise, because I think this can be really helpful to anyone reading this, and I don't want to risk boring you any further. 

He stepped away, we sat down, we got ourselves together. (His tension had risen too - turns out, he doesn't like to be crowded with imaginary people either.) We talked about what just happened. We chatted, maybe joked, relaxed and reflected. And just when I was almost back to baseline:

"Okay. Let's do it again."

Dude, I - I really, really don't want to.

"I know. But please trust me, you have to do it again. You'll see."

We got in our same place, and he told me about the people, staring, judging. This time, it took only two minutes to get me to the tension level I was before, which is maybe 65%. The sweat started to roll again, and my neck was getting that freshly-slapped feeling I know so well. 

"Okay. Tell your body what you need to tell it."

I took the deepest breath I could. "It is perfectly okay for my neck to feel exposed, for my body to sweat, for my pulse to race. It's okay because once I accept it, my tension will fall."

The tension in my neck spilled onto my cheeks. My heart rate went up.

This wasn't right. 

"I give my heart permission - I give it -  dude, this isn't working. I don't like this please stop, please make it stop please."

"Matt. You just said 'if I accept it, my tension will fall.' That isn't how it works. You're giving it a condition, and panic doesn't accept conditions. You just gave energy to your tension. Don't do that - just accept it. Accept what you're feeling."

I did, to a degree, but I was struggling and really thrown. He let me off the hook, stepped away, and gave me another little grounding exercise to do.

But you see what happened? These attacks don't respond to reason, and they certainly don't respond to if/then logic. I told myself I could make it go away, when I should have just been telling myself to let it happen, to feel my heart race and think "that's okay. In fact, that's good." To feel my neck get red and angry and think "that's okay, neck. You're doing fine. In fact, how cool is it that the body reacts like this." To feel my legs turn to rubber and think "that's okay, legs. You go ahead and get rubbery. People take expensive drugs to feel like this - thank you for letting me feel it all on your own."

So yeah. I'm not remotely there yet. I have to practice, which I'm not looking forward to. But I really need it. My life is too good to have these odd little interruptions scuttle my momentum. That was an incredibly intense hour, and it had an emotional and physical effect on me I'm still feeling, some 32 hours later. But man, what a lesson. So if accepting the anxiety is what I gotta do, I'll be more accepting than an 80s German metal band with a chubby lead singer in K-mart clothes.

       I went a long, long way for that last reference. That's commitment, yo.

Calmly yours,
Matt

MORE
4/2 '16 9 Comments
Thanks for this. Your therapist went in a direction I never would have imagined.
This therapist is a miracle worker.
I love your therapist. In a totally non-weird way.
I have to ask: is your therapist a follower of Peter Levine/Somatic Experiencing therapy? Levine is renowned for his work on trauma and anxiety, and your therapist sounds like he at least borrows from some of Levine's work. (Levine is brilliant in my opinion; actually the whole Levine tribe is probably a pack of geniuses as I used to see his brother Robert for acupuncture.) Anyway, when I developed PTSD/anxiety following a couple of closely-spaced major car accidents, I found an SE therapist who combined SE with hands on body work (she was also a massage therapist). So incredibly helpful for me! I mean, duh. I'm a massage therapist, so of course massage would work well for me. Ultimately though, I think it also just took TIME, lots of time (and lots of one particular breathing exercise that actually forces cortisol levels in the body to fall; yay science!).

Hmmm. You're a musician... I wonder (if you're not already) if somehow combining music/singing with your therapy would boost it.

Okay, I'll stop nerding out about this stuff now.
Anne, I'm sorry it's taken me three months to answer. (In my defense, it was a difficult question. :) )

Yes, my guy likes Levine and SE. My previous therapist did too, but he was WAY too into...that...culty thing that EST became. The name escapes me, which is hard to believe, as Fran (the previous guy) was really into it and talked about it every session. He desperately wanted me to attend. It's one of those 2-day things where you don't really have time to eat, and you get yelled at and you have to call people and make lists and stuff. Lots of folks like it; many others think it uses cult-like methods to trick you into thinking you've been cured. I dunno. I just know I have a natural aversion to such tactics; as soon as I feel it "working" I'll find a way to shut it down. Anyway, when I discovered Fran was one of their speakers and recruiting people was part of his responsibilities, I quit him. Felt super-creepy.

But none of that Peter Levine's fault. :)

I don't nerd out about my own anxiety enough, to be honest. I can dive into the most minute detail about recording pop songs, or who played bass for what and how this chord sounds against that one, but when it comes to, like, my own self-improvement, I put up a wall. Yes, music helps, in many ways - I like to put on headphones and certain music, and sometimes picking up a guitar and playing chords gets my brain in a much better place. I also recently realized some songs I wrote and recorded in the 2000s are actually about my own anxiety; I honestly had no idea at the time. (I ain't too bright.)

LANDMARK! That's what it's called now. Landmark Worldwide. Yep. People do like them, but...I can't. I just can't.

Jill and I like to go to a "petting zoo," I guess you'd call it, 50 minutes away. The place is literally wild - ducks, geese, and chickens walk around free, often demanding you feed them. Pigs & hogs, goats, llamas, and other wonderful creatures are also there, hoping you'll share some eucalyptus leaves or dried corn with them. (Sometimes the denizens get a little aggressive; one asshole cock kicked Jill hard, drawing blood. I'm amazed the keepers haven't been sued.) Anyway, going there is incredibly therapeutic. I'm calm and free of anxiety while I'm there, even when the foul are at their most demanding. Jill bonded with a pelican named Hemingway; there's a duck named Angel with whom I connect. She's got a damaged wing (it's called "angel wing" - ducks get it from eating too much bread offered by well-meaning park patrons) so she'll never fly, but she's doing okay anyway. We seem to get each other. And if she's not around, well, one cannot pet and feed a llama without feeling one's blood pressure drop 20 points. We don't have pets, so going there fills a hole for a while. And I'm generally good for a few days afterwards.

CBD is great too. :) As a preventative or a delayer, that is - once I'm roarin', I'm roarin', and the only recourse is to let it roar.

But animals - just - wow. I never use the term "cat lady" derisively; in my book, shut-ins who care for multiple felines win at life.
Oh wow. Yeah, Landmark used to be The Forum used to be EST. Werner Erhart founded it, didn't he? Freaky deaky guy as I recall. I participated in a couple of Forum seminars back in the day--but not because anyone was nagging me to do it; I was just my usual monkey curious self. I came away with a few interesting and useful tricks to keep in my mental toolbox, as well as the impression that the whole thing was a culty-pyramid schemey kind of operation. I would never in a million years, though, have connected Levine's work with that. Is there some connection between the two that I don't know about, or is it just coincidence that your therapist was really into both? How weird.

I love those petting zoo/free range kinds of places! But I'm stupid for critters in general; I seem to collect them...
I've been a massage therapist for... shit, almost 30 years now. Wow. Dang. Sorry, tangent.

Anyway, I've done it for a long time. And there is one, count 'em, ONE instruction that I was given in my initial training that has remained at the core of my work.

"Don't go after tension. Allow it to rise to the surface." ["Why not?" I asked. "Aren't I supposed to be DOING something?" "Nope. Don't get in a fight with it; you'll lose. Allow it to come to you, and then just sit with it."] Which made no sense to me at the time I was learning it, and it sounded mostly like New Age crap to my ears, but being a studious sort of student, I followed instructions. In class, on clients, and eventually in a much broader sense in my own life. Turns out it works! You sit with something, unconditionally, and that gives it the space to transform.

Quite recently, I was tumbling down a rabbit hole of anxiety and fear which kept me from getting up on stage. And I was all pissed off and confused. I'm not anxious about being on stage! Why is this fear eating me alive??! This is bullshit! Then I heard a snippet of a radio program while driving, about personifying ones fear, actually talking to it and THANKING it for, you know, all the times in your life where fear was actually useful and kept you safe. And the second thing that happened, a wise and dear friend listened to me pissing and moaning about not being able to get on stage, and she [politely kept from rolling her eyes and] said, "You know, why don't you just listen to that and accept it? Give yourself permission to be okay with being anxious and not getting on stage. So what, if now is not the time?"

And I was like, oh right. Just let it rise.

And while my stage fright hasn't completely evaporated, it's back down to reasonable and rational levels, the sort of nervous tension one expects to have, the kind that isn't debilitating. It flares up now and again, and I ... I just sit with it.

Thanks for telling your story; it's SUCH a good reminder of how capable we humans are of transformation. Somehow it didn't click until I read it that I was struggling all over again with something I supposedly learned 30 years ago. But I guess that's the nature of these things. We learn them, and then we relearn them, and then we relearn them again. Context after context after context.
What a wonderful response. Thank you so much for sharing all this.

My therapist shared his own issues with anxiety, and how he deals with it, and it always comes down to the same thing: fighting feeds it. I love the imagery you provided - let that tension rise so it can just...dissipate into the air.

It really is weird how hard that is to do sometimes. I'm overwhelmed with the deisre to either run or fight it off. And sure enough - all I do in those moments is feed it.

Again, thank you so much for this beautiful response. :)
My brain is in such a funk today that when I read the first line of your post, I thought, "Oh no! He just said, 'Thanks for sharing,'" and I mentally cringed the way a roly poly bug curls up when you touch it.

But then I read the rest and felt all better again. :)
 

First off: this is a ridiculous premise. There's no such thing as a "music problem." 

And yet...I have one. My iTunes music library currently stands at 18483 items - if I listened to one song at a time without sleeping, I'd be entertained for almost 48 days straight before I heard any repeats. I'd also probably be dead, but that's another story. 

               Not that you want proof for something like this, but here it is
               anyway. Note my careful choosing of visible cool band/album
               in my totally "random screenshot." No novice, I.

But my song collection isn't my problem. Even though it's become a cliché to say it (or tiresome, at the very least), my tastes really have always been all over the place. I'm not one of those knew-'em-before-they-were-cool hipsters - while I understand the painful joy of watching the world discover your favorite "secret" indie musician, most of the indies I love remain stubbornly undiscovered. But while I'm not much for genre, my iTunes and iPod (until they invent a phone that can hold 200 gigs o' music, I'm sticking with the Pod - and fuck Spotify in its nasty little o) is loaded with hefty amounts of R&B, country, hip-hop, mellow gold, jazz, folk, and, of course, rock and its many subgenres (metal, punk, oldie, indie, corporatie, progressivie, singer-songwriterie, super-abrasive avant-garde screamo jazz, Tom Waits, and pop). 

So far, so what, right? We're all collectors, and it's only natural for a musician to gather up all the music he/she can get his/her ears on. And it's just as natural to want to organize your spoils a bit, and sometimes organization goes a bit beyond the Apple-offered categories. 

Thus, the Playlist

The Playlist is a bit of a bugaboo for all of us who used to practice the Art of the Mixtape, back when a mixtape was a cassette. A Maxell XLII-S 90 was mandatory - pricey, but you don't serve 19-year-old Glenfiddich Bourbon Cask in a Solo Cup. Speaking of art - mixtapes took time, man. They took planning (which usually began in history class). They had themes, they were living, breathing entities. Making a mixtape a commitment, and the execution was pure zen - all encompassing, from concept to actual recording (better get those levels and gaps right - you'll want a couple seconds after "Until the Night"), and ultimately life-affirming and cathartic. And listening to one, whether it was a gift or self-made, was a proud, active experience.

         Come to me, Max. I wish to demonstrate how perfectly "The Card
         Cheat" leads into "Dancing Barefoot" into "All Good Times are Past
         and Gone" into "Swan Song H" into "Black Night White Light" into...


I'll be writing about mixtapes in another entry, probably with the assistance of Jill "xtingu" Knapp, a Mighty Mixtape Maker herself. But I'm really here to talk about playlists. The thing is, they take very little effort - you just slide the song into the folder, and if you change your mind, you x it out. You can take great pains to put the songs in proper order, of course - I certainly do - but I'm not sure why, as even I often give in to that tempting "Shuffle" button. Sure, few gifts give me a bigger smile than a nice, thoughtful Mix CD, but the effort of the creation was always a major part of the charm (of course, we've all received not-really-welcome mixtape gift from admirers, and knowing they put in several hours can ramp up the discomfort exponentially). There's a lot to be said about the digital age of music - while I hate how easy it is to steal music, I love how easy it is to buy, how easy it is to distribute, how it will always sound great - but we lost something when drawers full of cassettes, milk crates full of records, and shelves and shelves full of CDs are replaced by laptops, phones, and spreadsheets.

But still...I fucking love playlists.

And I am fucking addicted to them.

Remember when I bragged about the diversity of my collection? Well, it appears some insane synapse deep in my psyche wants to organize it. So while some of my playlists are practical or straightforward - 80's music<sup>1</sup>, Metal, and Instrumentals are all WYSIWYG, as are the ones containing every Billy Joel and Tom Waits song in chronological order - and some  leave more space for personal interpretation (Garage, Acoustic Chill, and Funk n' Motown) - some are...well...let's call them "esoteric." And they almost always start with a single thought about a single song.

Example: my Winter, Spring, Summer, Fall playlists. They began a year ago when I listened to "Man on the Moon," and it occurred to me that acoustic-driven, earthy alt-rock feels like a warm flannel jacket against a crisp autumn breeze and the smell of burning leaves (doesn't it?), and you know what, so does Richard Julian's "Don't Wait Up," and "The Thing About Boats," and I wonder how many other songs in iTunes feel like fall?

So I create the playlist, sort the spreadsheet by "Artist," and start scrolling through, looking for other autumnal tunes. Remember - I've got over 18,000 songs. Even with focus, it takes some time to get from Aaron Nathans & Michael G. Rondstadt to 5th Dimension (sorry, ZZ Top, but iTunes put numbers at the bottom). But I have the attention span of a flea hanging out at a meth lab, which means detours are inevitable. Oh, there's Bill Finley's "Faust," from Phantom of the Paradise - that's fall-like, sure, but it's also piano-based acoustic rock. Do I have a playlist for that? No? Well, let's just make one of those! Okay, back to the top, just in case I missed anyone.

Oh, while I'm doing that, you know what? It's not fair to just have a Fall playlist. Sure, it's my favorite season, but you don't turn down a Snickers just because it's not a Reese's PBC. So let's add Winter, Spring, and Summer, and...yeah, I better start at the top again. But this is tricky: "Thunder Road" is definitely summer, but "Darkness on the Edge of Town?" Is that winter? Does it even have a season? I don't know. But you know what "Darkness" is? Big. It's a big song. Sometimes I wanna hear big songs, you know? So...

You guessed it. Another playlist. Another several hours. Another several detours.

Guys, I can't stop. I've got a problem. I mentioned Acoustic Chill, but there's also Zone and Mellow Gold and Psychedelic Chill, and while there are some overlaps, I need them both. There's E-Dance, which is electronica, and Dance, Sucka, which is loaded with R&B and funk, and Funk n' Motown, which - but no, it's not the same as Dance, Sucka, you see? There's a difference in tone, in attitude. Just as Oldies, loaded with 50s & early 60s rock n' roll, is not to be confused with Nostalgia, fulla songs that marked personal milestones for me. But then why not just put those songs in Matt's Favorites, a 1600-and-counting list for when I want a nice, safe shuffle? Because they aren't the same, that's why. Just like Big and Dinosaurs aren't the same, even though Dinosaurs are big songs too, and...

So yes, It's a problem. A music problem. I do listen to these playlists - I often fall asleep as they play, generally on shuffle, on my trusty little under-the-pillow speaker - but the creation is the monkey on my back.

What bothers me, honestly, is the solipsism of it all. I'm not creating anything new, or deploying my brain to conjure any useful insights that might prepare me for future challenges. I'm just rearranging my spoils. Playing in my own mud.

My own beautiful, beautiful, musical mud.

Now if you'll excuse me, I've got pointing, clicking, and dragging to do...

                                  Where are you going? Don't you want to
                                  help? JOIN ME OUR PLAYLIST KINDGOM
                                  SHALL RULE THE WORLD HA HA HA HA
                                  HA HA
hey seriously where are you going?

MORE
9/10 '15 1 Comment
I have to find the mix CD that a co-worker at AC Moore gave me so that I could truly understand him.
It started with "Stick Out Your Can, Here Comes The Garbage Man," and went downhill from there. It included "You can't get to Heaven on the Market-Frankford El."
I don't want to find it or share it, yet somehow, I do.
 

I absolutely love making music with Jill "xtingu" Knapp . Love it will all my heart, liver, spleen, and other vital organs. Love it with all my soul, chakra, aura, and other vaguely mystikal terms that suggest life beyond this one. I even love it like a fat kid love cake. (Sorry about the bankrupcy, Fiddy. Something tells me you're gonna be just fine.)

Jill and I decided to go easy on the live shows this summer, especially once it became clear thatThe Big Reveal, the second full-length album from Hot Breakfast!, wouldn't be ready for a spring release. We decided October felt like a good month to drop an album - gives us of time to finish up without rushing, to get the artwork done, to book some "release parties," to dig into our savings account, to eat some fondue.

But opportunities kept sort of falling into our lap. And we are not ones to ignore the sage advice of the Pet Shop Boys, so we seized those opportunities, which led us to this lil' bullet list of What We've Played This Summer (so far).

  • We were a featured artist at Wilmo Wednesdays on May 20th. We were to be in Austin for the entire week, but after a Rube Goldbergian chain of events brought us home a couple days early, we agreed to jump on the bill. Highlights included: getting to see my great friend and brilliant songwriter Brian Turner perform for an audience for the first time in years; meeting Mark Thousands (a wonderful guy and excellent singer/songwriter/guitarist/tattoo canvas); and checking out Anatomy of an Outcast, a ridiculously young & friendly hard rock/punk/soul quartet.
  • We performed as a featured artist at McGillens Open Mic in Philly on June 11. We ended up seeing some really, really great acts and winning over a big, relatively young crowd, the majority of whom gleefully sang along with "Mr. Roboto," a song that charted, fell, and re-emerged as a cult classic before most of them had been born.
  • We played at Yachtstock River Jam at the Deck at Harbor Pointe, a massive event featuring a bevy** of great artists we know and love, like The Joe Trainor Trio, Danielle and Jennifer, and Kuf Knotz. Tommy Conwell headlined. It was a really well-organized event that had the misfortune to be scheduled for June 27th - a day loaded with vicious thunderstorms and hurricane winds. Nearly half of the bands pulled out, and many who showed packed up and left immediately after their set. But while I didn't play well at all, by the end of our set, the 20 or so folks in the room had gathered around our stage, wondering "who are these wacky dorks singing about drunk guys named Larry and pants?" We also sold some CDs, added a buncha folks to our mailing list, and impressed the event's organizer, a guy who looked a bit like Sam Elliott in Roadhouse (read: a guy you absolutely want on your side during a barfight).
  • July 3rd saw us opening for the Dead Milkmen at Crash! Bang! Boom!, the punk clothing store just off South Street that used to be Zipperhead, in an all-acoustic (no mics), invite-only show. That photo* up top, with Jill n' me singin' to a packed house in a hot clothing store? This is the coolest I have ever been. Here's a review from the owner, the lead singer/guitarist of awesome punk/goth/metal band Live Not On Evil. Best of all, our friends Kevin & Julie Regan were able to score invites.
  • On July 15, we were asked to substitute for The Sun Flights, a band that sadly had to drop from the Ladybug Festival lineup due to an impending death in the family. So the next day, July 16th, we squoze Janice, my Mini Cooper S, into the last parking spot in all of Wilmington (I love Janice) to perform a half-hour set at Film Bros. on 2nd & Market, and MAN did we have fun. Our set went really well - we had a packed house that kept getting packedier (there was live music and open doors in a three-block area, so people could come and go as they pleased), and we got to spend some time with Joe & Kerry while seeing tons of old friends while catching some terrific sets from Margot McDonald, Sarah Koon, and Rachel Schain and the Comic Book Geeks. We made some friends, got recognized (always a kick), and thoroughly enjoyed the vibe and energy of one of the most beautiful nights of the year. Just seemed like everyone was happy, and every artist knocked it out of the park. We really wish we could have seen more musicians, but it was so great to be a part of it all, especially considering Gable Music Ventures turned us down for Ladybug a couple years ago.
  • Say hi to Marshall. He was a guest of Joe, the Dead Milkmen's guitarist/singer (the "Punk Rock Girl" guy), at the DM's Crash! Bang! Boom! show. He's young and good-looking he and Jill chatted n' flirted like old friends much of the night, and then he asked us to perform with his punk band Sherwin in Lancaster for their final show on July 17 before he moved to Japan. So last night, we round-tripped it to a wonderful little punk dive/restaurant called the American Bar and Grill. And Holy crap, did we have a ball. Not only did we get to meet up with our friend Georgie, one of the most awesome people on the planet, but we ate some killer grub (chicken-pesto pizza for me, tenderloin tip salad for Jill) (I know, right? We're in DDD territory here!) and pulled out one of our best, tightest performances to date.
  • Now, the ABG is basically two small rooms - one has bar in the center, which boasts an impressive beer/whiskey selection, while the other is a small dining room until 9 or so, when they tear down the tables and set up the PA and turn it into a "stage." The Dead Scouts opened at 9:30, putting the fog machine and stage lighting they provided to nice use. I loved how the beautiful, trippy guitar tones countered the hardcore-inspired vocals (think Fucked Up, a that wonderfully incongruous Canadian post-hardcore outfit). Good band, but so loud it was hard to stay in the room with them - maybe 6 people hung in there for the set. So when we stepped up for our half-hour at 10:15, we could tell the patrons were thinking "the hell are these guys doing here?" Well, we tell thee what, Doubting Levi, we're here to rock your lovingly hand-woven socks off, pal.*** By the end of our 6-song set over half of the crowd from the bar had piled into the stage room to witness the dork-rockitude and sing along with "Total Eclipse of the Heart." It was glorious. More on this in a bit.
  • Anyway, then Sherwin - Marshall's band - came on. We had an 80-minute drive ahead of us, and we were already beat from an unexpectedly long Thursday. Before they started, we figured we'd give them a polite 20-minute listen before heading out. But ten minutes after they began, we knew they could have played 'til dawn and we weren't going ANYWHERE. They were seriously that good, mixing old-school punk with hardcore, rock n' roll, a touch of metal, and incredibly intense & honest vocals. Marshall rocked the drums - looking deceptively laid-back but driving every song, but every band member was top-notch, and the songwriting was incredible, merging influences from bands as diverse as Against Me!, The Clash, Minor Threat & Fugazi, Gorilla Biscuits, Bad Brains, even maybe some Black Flag. Best of all, they played the SHIT out of it, with a super-tight rhythm section and some of the best rhythm guitar playing I've ever heard. Bottom line: we love Marhsall, we love Sherwin, and I hope this music will live on somehow while he's 7,000 miles away. 

That brings us to today. 

After reading this over, I realize I've wandered off topic a bit. I was going to talk about how we sometimes have a hard time getting out of the house, either due to health- or social-anxiety, but we're almost happy when we do. We love our people, we really don't see them enough, and gigs are a great way of not only getting out and saying hi, but also connecting and reconnecting.

And that's all true, but instead, I'm gonna bore you with schmoop about Jill. Sorry. But here's the deal:

I love making music with Jill Knapp.

Whether we're performing at a gig, practicing at home or at our buddy Jeff Dement's house for a big Billy Joel Tribute show, recording a new song in the studio, or quietly learning a new song I wrote (one of the most intimate things we do together), I sometimes just realize how this gives me life. As we were halfway through our over-the-top take on "Total Eclipse" at ABG, I glanced at her as she gave it her all, combining theatricality with sincerity with comedy, selling it with her absolutely incredible voice,. and once again, I was overcome with how lucky I am to be this guy, to not only get to share our lives, but to share our music and our musical minds.

My fall is going to be devoted to getting people to listen to our album. We want it in stores, on radio stations, in homes, in everyone's iPod or iPhone or whatever new iDevice we'll all need six years from now. We believe in it. Look, it's only rock and roll - some songs are silly, some deeper, some tossed off in 15-minutes, some agonized over, some loud n' punky, some soft n' groovy. But ultimately it's just music, something most people maybe have on in the background as they drive to work, something to distract us in the gym. And that's cool - that's we need music for all that. But I've come to realize I'm at the peak of my communication skills when we perform as our silly, gimmicky duo. I want people to actually sit and listen, like we did in the old days. Not just because I wrote the music, or because we worked so hard on it. It's because when Jill sings the words, she's singing that indescribable thing that is us. And that's what I have to offer.

As I watch and listen to her sing, I'm filled with...something I can't explain. Love, yes, of course - more love than I ever knew possible. But when I listen to our music, whether live or captured on a buncha 1s & 0s, the combination of our efforts that created those sounds fills me with something that is probably the closest I will ever feel to believing in God.

That's right. "Hole in Your Pants" ain't just dorky. It's divinely dorky.

- Matt

* Speaking of, that photo up top was taken by Dean Clean. (Yep - I'm milking this "cool" think for all it's worth.)

** Congratulations, as you have witnessed the first and final time I shall deliberately use that word in print. 

*** That's right - three Amish jokes in one sentence. BURN! Or should I say...CHURN?***

****I'll just see myself out.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

MORE
7/19 '15 2 Comments
I am tingling with anticipation!
I love you both.
 

Here are some questions for you good people:

Do athiests have a "belief?" Or is atheism a lack of belief? Is it a leap of faith to believe there are no gods, or are athiests standing firmly on the ground by disbelieving in all gods?

In a few other words: is athiesm science, religion, philosophy, or a combination thereof? And - this one's for those who consider themselves atheists - does it matter? Is the difference between "I believe there are no gods" and "I disbelieve in all gods" important?

I have an opinion, but I'm much more interested in yours. Besides, who the hell am I to say? I think Ewoks are awesome and Tyler, the Creator is the best thing to happen to music since Smear joined the Foos for good. So maybe I'm not the best one to judge.

                                                             Yep. This guy.

So there you have it! Fire away. You're welcome to bring your own belief system into the discussion, but it isn't necessary. Politeness and respect is, though, but y'all knew that already.

Thanks! And if I accidentally earwormed you with George Michael, well...you're welcome

MORE
5/25 '15 8 Comments
When I married Jason, the Rabbi who married U.S. said that Jason's atheism was stronger than my Judaism. One time he asked him, "Tell me about the God you don't believe in." Jason had a very clear picture in his mind of that nonexistent God.
Us, not U.S.
I do not find existential comfort in systems that rely on faith rather than evidence. However, I do think there is self-comfort to be found in the performance of kindness to other beings. Further, faith-based systems that emphasise and encourage the practice of that sort of kindness seem to be very useful templates for behaviour patterns, if not internal mental states.

So, even if I don't subscribe to a literal interpretation of the writings of and about Gautama Buddha, I still don't mind calling myself a Buddhist, as it gives others an easy shorthand understanding of my behaviour patterns and my regard for other beings.
On reflection, I probably shouldn't say I'm a Buddhist. That's appropriation: saying one is a thing, when one isn't. I guess I could say I have Buddhist-like behaviour patterns. Or I could just call myself a Humanist. That would probably be best.
Thomas Jefferson was also a humanist so you'd be in good company.
A long time ago I described myself as militantly agnostic: "I don't know if there's a God, and you don't either."

I took this stance partly in response to people who thought atheism was "wimpy," but mainly because I was drawing a distinction between a view held on the basis of the available evidence (which, to my mind, was essentially nil either way) and a view held because you'd like things to be that way ("I don't like the idea of God, or the people who believe in God"). The former can pretend to being objective, the latter is on no firmer ground than fundamentalism.

Later I read some of Stephen Hawking's pop-science stuff and decided that the evidence suggested an omnipotent creator is unnecessary to get us to where we are; the weak anthropic principle, and the possibility of many universes, are sufficient explanation. So I became an atheist, but not an especially vehement one, because it's tricky to rule out the possibility that something chose the initial conditions. Occam's Razor isn't an iron-clad guarantee.

One more thought that helped me put my views in perspective: I realized that the fear of damnation wasn't much of a motivation for me. That is, even if pascal's wager wasn't fundamentally flawed to begin with (*), it is cowardly not to live in accordance with your own ethical beliefs. I didn't want to obey some of the more reprehensible bits of Leviticus or punish others who did not do so, even if it meant I'd be in trouble down the road. And a God who wouldn't expect me to was at least as likely to exist anyway.

That is still essentially where I sit. I agree it's a very different animal from the viewpoint of an atheist who speaks of nothing but how Catholic he isn't.

But can we draw any useful conclusions from this about the average atheist? I don't know; has anyone surveyed self-identified atheists to find out if their viewpoint is more like mine, or more like that of Shelle's ex?

(*) Because a God who demands the opposite of all the rules you've been following "just in case" is equally probable.
what's the term for someone who simply has no interest in questions of god, gods, his/her/their existence, and his/her/their role in human life?

I neither believe nor disbelieve nor consider it an open question. I'm not interested enough in the problem to want to bother.
You read my mind.
 

We played a 15-minute gig to open up the Homey Award Show on Friday.

Jill was awesome, and I say that with as much objectivity as possible. She nailed it. Me, I was eh. Made only one "mistake," really, and it wasn't major (of course, I nailed it in rehearsal). But I wasn't particularly on - I was a little too self-conscious to really play.

But I've certainly been a lot worse, and on those occasions I never gave it any more thought than "hey, they can't all be your best show" or "sometimes your fingers have minds of their own" and other musician clichés. For those who've never seen us, there's a lot of "act" in our act, which gives us a little cover, making it easier to fake-till-ya-make. So a flub here and there is no big deal, right?

Well, maybe it's because we were in a room of fantastic musicians, or maybe it's because my panic attack last week was the first strike of a deep-seeded, long-planned Revolution of the Brain, but my first thought after taking our bow (to a semi-standing O, no less) and running off stage was, and I quote: "I am a fraud."

Not "I  kind of sucked tonight," or "that was disappointing," but "I am a huge fucking fraud, and everybody knows it."

Not exactly fair, brain. 

                                            You used to be cool, dude.

Look, those aforementioned clichés are true - little flubs happen, and no one cares. I'm experienced (read: old) enough to know that although my guitar acumen is just barely strong enough to justify my presence on a stage, my strength is in performing, in connecting with the crowd, in being Kage to Jill's Jables. But when we tell people "what we lack in talent we make up in cheap theatrics," we're only joking about one of us. I can write, but I lack the performance skillz; cheap theatrics is all I got. 

Before I go further: this post is not a plea for praise and attention. That's not why I'm sharing this, I promise. In fact, I fear such responses, well-meaning and sincere as they are, can sometimes make my problem worse.

So to be on the verge of tears of humiliation after an ultimately successful, borderline triumphant gig - especially considering how few people in the room were even interested in live music - is to know that some neurotransmitter ain't transmittin' right. And to have that "FRAUD" feeling only triple in size and volume after winning the "Best Live Act" award means this might ultimately be a job too powerful for Xanax. 

Speaking of: after we won that trophy, I texted this to Joe Trainor (who was happily sharing our table): "I seriously cannot shake the feeling like I'm a fraud" (apparently whatever synapse zapped my confidence was also responsible for grammar). He walked up next to me and gave me a "what the fuck!?" look, telling me the show was strong (I trust him to be 100% honest about that) and I was being ridiculous. I explained the feeling the best I could, asking him if he'd ever felt that. 

He thought about it for a bit, and said "not really. But I think I'm objective enough to know that I'm a good player and singer, and subjective enough to really like and believe in my songs. So, fraudulent? I've had moments where I felt like I wasn't performing up to my own standards, but I never felt fraudulent. Disappointed? Sometimes. Disillusioned? Definitely."

He's right - he's one of the few musicians/actors/writers I know with an accurate assessment of his own talent, which is a rare but vital skill for those of us in the biz. But I think I'm pretty good at that too, and that's not an entirely comforting feeling right now. 

I dunno. I got over it before the night was over (one Xanax! Two Xanaxes! Ah, ah, ah!) and ended up having a great time. Our performance earned us at least three potential gigs, and I could not be prouder of Hot Breakfast! and all we've accomplished. And even though I'm writing this on maybe three hours of sleep, leaving my filter filled with holes, I'm still having a hard time conjuring up that "fraud" feeling I keep talking about. So maybe it was fleeting, and this, like All Things, must pass. 

But still, I'm gonna keep one eye on my brain for a little while. Just in case it's up to some old (and new) nasty tricks. I'm too happy for this nonsense. 

MORE
Hello, I am Shelle. I am pretending to be a real adult. Some day, someone will find out that I am just an immature jackass in an adult's body and they will call bullshit on my life, haul my children away to social services and give my grown-ass-woman Systems Analyst job to someone who deserves it.

I don't think this of myself every day (most days I'm too busy to reflect on my qualifications), but often enough that it's notable.

Also, you are a musician and you are judging yourself with a musician's ears. Most of your audience is just a bunch of musical laypeople, and we love your act, so you're good enough to be doing what you're doing and making people happy. You are probably also better than you think you are, because your inner critic sounds like he's a real asshole ... but I am not a trained musician, so all I can tell you is that when I go to an HB! show, I have fun and get lost in the music. I do not think, "Jill rocks, but that Casarino guy is not quite there yet." And if I did, well, I probably wouldn't tell you, but I certainly wouldn't tell you the opposite because I am Not That Nice. Ask Jill, she knows me pretty well.
Bwa, ha, ha! I'm a fraud and I'm getting away with it! There's nothing better.
MATT CASARINO likes this.
I love you so much. After I get home on Wednesday (hopefully freshly-healed myself from the antibiotics & steroids having a chance to work their magic) we can come up with a plan. I'm so happy we'll be together for the next three weeks having adventures in NYC and then at SXSW-- and the SXSW shows are all relatively low-stakes shows as you know. We've got this. We're a team, and I will do everything in my power to be the best, supportive partner I can be, just like you've been during these weeks of my plague.

You are not a fraud. There is nobody, NOBODY, I would rather share a stage with. Not IJG, not any of the big bands we've played with, nobody. It is an honor to make music with you, and I think you're a hell of a guitar player.

Plus you're really cute.

I love you endlessly.

(Apologies to everyone else for having to read this under-the-hood schmoop.)
Imposter Syndrome is frequent among people who Make Stuff Up (songs, poems, movies, plays, novels, legal briefs, scientific formulae, etc. etc. etc.) . The more innovative you are, the more you feel like, "what if this thing I'm making up is entirely false?"

Why do you think Truman Capote drank so much?


Just know that you are in good company. It's either a bug or a feature. I'm not entirely sure which. Know that at least you're smart enough to not completely see your work with rose-colored glasses, and know that Imposter Syndrome does happen to the best of us.

Seriously.

Neil Gaiman? Check. Sonia Sotomayor? Check. Albert Einstein? Yup.
And on and on and on. It's not just a sales trick to make some artists seem more human.
http://www.news.com.au/finance/highachievers-suffering-from-imposter-syndrome/story-e6frfm1i-1226779707766

Basically, just tell yourself, "there's that news van again," or whatever, when you feel it coming up. Tell yourself whatever you want. I usually say, "Oh, hi, it's you again, asshole," imagining a dirty black bird perching on my shoulder. and I yell shoo at it. IN MAH MIND.
Thank you for voicing this, Matt. I must echo what others have said above: clearly, sir, you are no fraud. Nor are you alone in the sensation that you may be. I am masquerading around in an adult costume, running a medical journal, pretending to be a writer (ha!), owning a home, driving around in car .... but oh, the talk in my head tells me that, any moment now, the Adulthood Police are going to find me out and take me away. We are all winging it in some way or another. Every night can't be your best night. But, even when you are a little off, you are so, so good. I've seen you guys play enough times to imagine I've witnessed performances where you may have felt fantastic, and others where you have felt not-so-great. But every show I've seen has been joyously entertaining. If you missed a note, no one noticed but Jill, and she still loves you.* Anyway, it's ok. You'll hit it next time. xo

*see schmooptastic comment above.
Also, FWIW: There may be a "it's that time of year" thing going on. March Madness, if you will. I think there's something in the collective subconscious that's reacting oddly to being at damn near 12 weeks of winter, plus 12 weeks of fall after that. I think everyone's feeling near a breaking point. you're not alone.
Yesterday I announced I would be giving a casual talk to my coworkers about How Secure Websites Work. The boss said, "can we record this one?" I said "sure!"

And then I started to panic as I realized it's been over 20 years since I touched the math involved. Or, like, touched math.

This was ridiculous. Although I am certainly not a mathematician, I am a more than capable programmer and an expert communicator. There was no way I wasn't gonna come up with an awesome little talk by morning.

And now I'm kinda pissed we didn't record it after all.
So...how DO secure websites work? Violence?
Cats in Stormtrooper helmets. They're called Stormpoopers.
I think some Philadelian had this idea a few years ago (was it Lindsay? Was it Tom? Was it Shelle? Was it MattL? Was it me? I don't even know, sweartagahd) that we should have a monthly/quarterly Philadel Salon-- where we Philadels get together and a few people get scheduled on an evening to give a 30-minute talk/presentation/activity on anything they want. If Lindsay has a play she's working on, we can take 30 mins to hear her explain it for 10 and us to read for 10 and discuss for 10. If Tom wants to teach us how Secure Websites Work, we'd love to learn about it. If MattL wants to show everyone how to draw rippling biceps, rock and roll! If MattC has a new song he wants to introduce, or Shelle has a new passage she wrote, whip it out!

It'd be a neat way for us to learn new stuff, both on the giving and receiving end.

We're all probably too busy to do this, but I think it'd be fun.
I think we talked about this, but space was a consideration. It was more of a "I have a skill which you might want to learn," so having Bobbi teach improv games, or Jenn or Tom teach dance, were things on the menu. so it was something which required space.

Your idea, though, of sharing the thing on which one is working, might require less space. or space could depend on activity. or something.
Always liked this idea.
 

This is a public service announcement. Or something. What it isn't is your author bragging about some mental disorder. I promise.

I had an anxiety attack today - my first in a couple years. I was grocery shopping and had an overwhelming, all-encompassing, and utterly irrational urge to stock up on paper plates immediately. "If you don't purchase paper plates right now," my brain explained, "everything is gonna fall apart. Lives will be ruined, the time-space continuum will shatter, Limp Bizkit will release another album." This was serious. I was fixated, I was in a loop, and the only prescription was more paper plates. 

                                  This guy knows what I'm talkin' about.


I put several packages of paper plates in my cart and strolled over to the tea aisle, figuring that was the end of that. But while searching for Red Zinger, I realized I my pulse was racing and my breathing shallow - I was as tense as an unarmed Ted Nugent on a Disney Animal Kingdom safari ride. Now Red Zinger can be tough to find, but it's hardly worth that much stress. That's when it hit me. "Holy cow," I thought, as I'm apparently a character in 50 Shades of Gray. "I'm having a freakin' anxiety attack. Where the hell did that come from?"

At first, the I found the dichotomy hilarious - after at least 18 episode-free months, here I am panicking in the Safeway! I texted Jill "xtingu" Knapp to let her know what was going on, but she didn't have her phone handy, so she didn't get the message (if she had, she would have immediately walked to the supermarket and driven me home over my objections, because she's Jill). So I stuck to my task of buying up our snow n' ice storm supplies, even as the supermarket started to take on a nightmarish (but still amusing) funhouse-type atmosphere. "I'm buying butter during an anxiety attack," I thought. "I'm buying Fruit Loops, honey, Peppermint Patties, Bugles, and James Dean Pancake Batter-Wrapped sausages while I'm having an anxiety attack. This is kind of punk rock."*

But soon, it was more GG Allin than The Ramones. Consternation replaced my good humor. The tension in my spine, my quickening pulse, my utterly distracted mind, and my rising apprehension made shopping - and especially being around people - more and more impossible. This wasn't funny anymore. I finally stashed my cart in the corner where no one goes (where they store things like raisins, Lunchables, and balut**) and ran out to my car, where I listened to 50s doo-wop for 30 minutes or so and breathed deeply, desperately trying to bring my epinephrine levels down.

Okay, this post is gonna get even duller if I stay on this "and then I..." path. Suffice to say, the Diamonds and the Five Satins calmed me enough to get back in the store and finish shopping (ice cream > panic), check out (thank Cthulhu for those self-scan checkout stations!), and drive home. I unloaded the groceries, hung up my new sports jacket***, and said hi to Jill, who took one look at me and said "To the bed. Right now."​

            She still hadn't seen my text, but this is pretty much what Jill saw.


A dose of Xanax later, I thought I was doing on the mend. I was still physically tense - it was a struggle to get myself out of the fetal position - but my mind was calmer and perspective was returning. I was having rational conversations (for me, anyway) and joking about the whole paper-plates-as-mashed-potatoes-in-Close Encounters fiasco. Plus, a couple hours had passed, so I smiled and sat up - 

- and then came the waterworks. Uncontrollable shaking and crying. 

Bottom line: four hours passed between that first text to Jill and the last of my tears. A short time after that I was perfectly fine (as fine as I get, anyway), ready to conquer great viewings of YouTube and maybe scratch out another verse in a new song probably I'll never finish. But four hours is my longest attack yet - they used to be 90 minutes, tops. 

I don't care for morals (clearly), but if there is a moral, it's this: these things happen, and it's not shameful or necessarily tied to unhappiness. Something misfires in the brain and next thing you know you're stashing your cart and running out to your car in the rain. Granted, these attacks first started when I was unhappy, when my life was a mess and getting messier and my attempts to find happiness were becoming increasingly damaging - they were outlets for emotions I refused to deal with. And when I finally did start dealing with them and tried to get my life back on track (with many stumbles and mistakes, of course), the attacks grew less frequent. And now? I'm deleriously happy. I'm not sublimating, I'm not swallowing, and while not everything is perfect, I'm living a wonderful life, and I'm madly, deeply, hopelessly in love with someone who brings me more joy than I ever thought possible. Sure, I have problems and issues, mostly (but not all) health-related, but the good far outweighs the bad. Shouldn't these episodes be in the past?

Nope. That's not how it works. Today, there it was: a tough little anxiety attack waiting to absolutely blindside me with a poke to my brain.

I swear I'm not trying to aggrandize myself as a courageous figure who must carry a monumental burden. Not even close. My worst attacks are quite mild compared to what many people experience - for them, panic feels like massive, paralyzing, terrifying heart attacks. In my case, it's a more of a glitch, a little misfire, a mini-zap to the brain that finds me no matter what my state of mind. It's no one's fault, and according to many informal surveys, it doesn't make me deep and interesting. ("Hey, am I deep and interesting because I -" "No." "Can I even finish the question?" "No.") But it sure can add a little excitement to a mundane day. 

If this has ever happened to you, please, please tell doctor. When these episodes began, I hid them for months before finally, reluctantly, shamefully admitting to my doctor's PA that I was too weak to face these attacks down and probably needed therapy and pharmaceutical help. She said something wonderful: "Stop beating yourself up. People get sad, they get overwhelmed. You're a human being with emotions, and it isn't a weakness to feel emotions. It's a strength." I do my best to remember that when I need to. Life is beautiful, but sometimes it's a lot harder than it should be, and if a tiny dose of Alprazolam and a good cry can help you through the rocky moments, make it so. And let yourself marvel at what a piece of work is the brain and the body.

By the way, if anyone can use a few paper plates, we've got enough to cater a Duggers' family reunion. (Which I will never, never do, because fuck those guys. I hope they never get to experience anxiety attacks.)



* QUIT JUDGING OUR SHOPPING LIST. It's...for the homeless, okay?

** If you're having a fine day, do not Google "balut." All will be lost. 

*** What, your supermarket doesn't have a Men's Clothiers section? Right next to Haberdashery and Shepstery? Weird.

MORE
3/4 '15 5 Comments
You are very brave to admit weakness, especially because you're a man. I mean that completely sincerely.

I am, and I have struggled with how to write this in a non-douchey way, I am glad that Jill was not available when you texted her. Here's why: what if Jill were teaching in California when this happened? She knows the man she love is in peril, she can't do anything, it's awful. Because she happened to be away from her phone, now you know and she knows that even if you have a terrible experience like you did yesterday, you can get yourself together and get yourself home. That's so important, that you know you can apply techniques like listening to music and being in a quiet space to get your mind and body to cooperate enough to get back online long enough to get you to a safe space (and with your task complete, even!).

Strength and weakness, I think, are not about the hand you are dealt, but how you deal with it. You had a shit hand dealt to you yesterday, you had to deal with it on your own, and you did it. Strong work, sir.
Thank you guys. Y'all rock :) Honestly, I feel like I'm making a bigger deal out of this than it really is just by writing it down. But I dunno, maybe someone might read it and recognize their own symptoms & behavior. Took me a little while to accept that it's nothing to be ashamed of.

And you're not being douchey in the least, Shellebot. I completely agree. I honestly only texted her because it's always easier to go through these attacks when someone else knows about them - I would have to be in a really bad way to ask her to come get me. But she's Jill, so she might have anyway. :) Or, she might have suggested/insisted I ditch the cart and come home immediately.

I'm just grateful to be reading something that strikes so close to home for me. I've even had the grocery store weirdness you're talking about. So, if anything, thanks for making one more person out there feel less alone. Yay for Xanax!
I agree with this comment.

Two days ago, I did something dumb, and panicked. I thought, I should call Vince. I didn't. instead, I looked up how to fix it and fixed it. then I calmed down.

I'm really sorry that this happened to you. It sucks. But I'm really proud of you for handling it the way you did.
Balut?
(google)
AUGH!
 

For a light entry before this Flexeril really kicks in and I fall into blissful slumber, I was going to post the five greatest double-takes in film history.

Unfortunately, even though I could have sworn I had a bunch of 'em in mind, right now I can only think of four, and two of 'em barely count as true double-takes. So I'm gonna edit my premise a bit and say these are the Greatest Moments of Sudden Realization in Movie History (or, as I like to call 'em, "Oh Shit" Moments). Every movie, play, and show should have at least one moment where somebody Suddenly Realizes Something and Nothing Is The Same.

Anyway, here's what I got for now. I'll talk around the spoilers, but still...spoilers. (But they're old spoilers, because I'm old.) And except for one or two entries, my list avoids mysteries and movies about people detecting things. But I'd love to make this sucker ongoing, so if you make with the comments, I'll make with the editin'. 

1. Tootsie
The Moment: Charles Durning realizes who's sitting next to him at the bar.

This here's my favorite double-take in film history, because it's so unusual - it's a slow-burn, rather than a quick, bug-eyed take. And it's masterfully done by an incredible actor. I could watch this on a loop.

2. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
The Moment: "You're Welcome."

Jack's face: priceless. 

3. Almost Famous
The Moment: He's HOW old??

Rock star Russell is on the phone with William's mother, thinking he can charm his way into calming her down. William's mother reveals William's age. Russell's reaction is great - his eyes are filled with surprise, and you can see the wheels turning as he processes the information. And best of all, once he hangs up the phone, we realize Russell has decided he doesn't really care how old William is - it's a non-issue. (Maybe that makes his girlfriend's age a non-issue as well? Let's hope so.)

Not that you asked, but Almost Famous is my favorite movie of the 2000s. 

4. Real Genius
The Moment: "Think about it."

The look on Val's ketchup-smeared face as Uncle Rico tells him what he's done gives me chills. Sure, Val built something that will be used for evil, but there's another layer: he suddenly realizes he was so caught up in innovation he didn't even consider the possible application of his creation. That the movie doesn't spell that second part out for you is a testament to its own genius. Oppenheimer probably went through the same thing. 

5. Usual Suspects
The Moment: Hey! That was my favorite mug, dude!

So over-the-top. So great anyway. 

6. The Godfather, Part 2
The Moment: "Johnny Ola told me about this place"

All Michael does is move his eyes. It's enough.

7. Diggstown
The Moment: <adjusts tie>

It's tough to be conned by a Big Reveal these days. We know all the tricks and the clues. We've seen The Sting. But Diggstown - a brutal, smart, shameless, wonderful little movie that deserved a much bigger audience than it found - succeeds in conning us, and it is beautiful. And it works because it plays fair. We shoulda seen it coming. We didn't. 

8. The Crying Game
The Moment: Oh, stop. You know what moment I'm talkin' bout.

Might not be fair to include this one - Stephen Rea doesn't exactly figure out the twist so much as have it shoved in his face (literally). But Rea does wonderful work here. On our first viewing, we're probably a little too stunned to notice (I accidentally learned the reveal before seeing the movie, so I can't say for sure, but I'm pretty sure I would have been fooled), but imagine everything Rea's character is going through at that moment, and note how well Rea conveys it all by downplaying. 

9. Jackie Brown
The Moment: Ordell figures it out

I'm cheating, because there's no reveal, and the realization isn't sudden. But I'm including it because Tarantino shows us something we never see in a movie: a character taking a moment to think. Ordell, framed so we less than half his face, turns his head and closes his eyes for 20 seconds before coming up with his answer. Ordell's tendency to think he's smarter than he actually is gets played for laughs in most of the movie; here, it turns out he's just smart enough. (Skip to 2:50 to see the moment.)

10. Primal Fear
The Moment: Heeeeeey. Wait a minute.

This one barely made my list. The twist is nifty, but the moment of revelation deserves a bigger impact than the movie provides. The problem is Norton's giveaway line. It's a little too giveaway - the audience processes the twist before the bulb goes off over Richard Gere's head, and that's all wrong. But the style is just so shameless - there's a close-up of Gere literally stopping in his tracks - that we allow it to work anyway. How can we be mad at a movie so eager to please us a great "oh shit" moment? 


So that's what I got. But I know I'm forgetting some great ones. Whadda YOU got, Wonders?

MORE
10/16 '14 1 Comment
I would love to use this list in a writing class. The "no turning back now" moment of any play is huge.