We played a 15-minute gig to open up the Homey Award Show on Friday.

Jill was awesome, and I say that with as much objectivity as possible. She nailed it. Me, I was eh. Made only one "mistake," really, and it wasn't major (of course, I nailed it in rehearsal). But I wasn't particularly on - I was a little too self-conscious to really play.

But I've certainly been a lot worse, and on those occasions I never gave it any more thought than "hey, they can't all be your best show" or "sometimes your fingers have minds of their own" and other musician clichés. For those who've never seen us, there's a lot of "act" in our act, which gives us a little cover, making it easier to fake-till-ya-make. So a flub here and there is no big deal, right?

Well, maybe it's because we were in a room of fantastic musicians, or maybe it's because my panic attack last week was the first strike of a deep-seeded, long-planned Revolution of the Brain, but my first thought after taking our bow (to a semi-standing O, no less) and running off stage was, and I quote: "I am a fraud."

Not "I  kind of sucked tonight," or "that was disappointing," but "I am a huge fucking fraud, and everybody knows it."

Not exactly fair, brain. 

                                            You used to be cool, dude.

Look, those aforementioned clichés are true - little flubs happen, and no one cares. I'm experienced (read: old) enough to know that although my guitar acumen is just barely strong enough to justify my presence on a stage, my strength is in performing, in connecting with the crowd, in being Kage to Jill's Jables. But when we tell people "what we lack in talent we make up in cheap theatrics," we're only joking about one of us. I can write, but I lack the performance skillz; cheap theatrics is all I got. 

Before I go further: this post is not a plea for praise and attention. That's not why I'm sharing this, I promise. In fact, I fear such responses, well-meaning and sincere as they are, can sometimes make my problem worse.

So to be on the verge of tears of humiliation after an ultimately successful, borderline triumphant gig - especially considering how few people in the room were even interested in live music - is to know that some neurotransmitter ain't transmittin' right. And to have that "FRAUD" feeling only triple in size and volume after winning the "Best Live Act" award means this might ultimately be a job too powerful for Xanax. 

Speaking of: after we won that trophy, I texted this to Joe Trainor (who was happily sharing our table): "I seriously cannot shake the feeling like I'm a fraud" (apparently whatever synapse zapped my confidence was also responsible for grammar). He walked up next to me and gave me a "what the fuck!?" look, telling me the show was strong (I trust him to be 100% honest about that) and I was being ridiculous. I explained the feeling the best I could, asking him if he'd ever felt that. 

He thought about it for a bit, and said "not really. But I think I'm objective enough to know that I'm a good player and singer, and subjective enough to really like and believe in my songs. So, fraudulent? I've had moments where I felt like I wasn't performing up to my own standards, but I never felt fraudulent. Disappointed? Sometimes. Disillusioned? Definitely."

He's right - he's one of the few musicians/actors/writers I know with an accurate assessment of his own talent, which is a rare but vital skill for those of us in the biz. But I think I'm pretty good at that too, and that's not an entirely comforting feeling right now. 

I dunno. I got over it before the night was over (one Xanax! Two Xanaxes! Ah, ah, ah!) and ended up having a great time. Our performance earned us at least three potential gigs, and I could not be prouder of Hot Breakfast! and all we've accomplished. And even though I'm writing this on maybe three hours of sleep, leaving my filter filled with holes, I'm still having a hard time conjuring up that "fraud" feeling I keep talking about. So maybe it was fleeting, and this, like All Things, must pass. 

But still, I'm gonna keep one eye on my brain for a little while. Just in case it's up to some old (and new) nasty tricks. I'm too happy for this nonsense. 

MORE
Hello, I am Shelle. I am pretending to be a real adult. Some day, someone will find out that I am just an immature jackass in an adult's body and they will call bullshit on my life, haul my children away to social services and give my grown-ass-woman Systems Analyst job to someone who deserves it.

I don't think this of myself every day (most days I'm too busy to reflect on my qualifications), but often enough that it's notable.

Also, you are a musician and you are judging yourself with a musician's ears. Most of your audience is just a bunch of musical laypeople, and we love your act, so you're good enough to be doing what you're doing and making people happy. You are probably also better than you think you are, because your inner critic sounds like he's a real asshole ... but I am not a trained musician, so all I can tell you is that when I go to an HB! show, I have fun and get lost in the music. I do not think, "Jill rocks, but that Casarino guy is not quite there yet." And if I did, well, I probably wouldn't tell you, but I certainly wouldn't tell you the opposite because I am Not That Nice. Ask Jill, she knows me pretty well.
Bwa, ha, ha! I'm a fraud and I'm getting away with it! There's nothing better.
MATT CASARINO likes this.
I love you so much. After I get home on Wednesday (hopefully freshly-healed myself from the antibiotics & steroids having a chance to work their magic) we can come up with a plan. I'm so happy we'll be together for the next three weeks having adventures in NYC and then at SXSW-- and the SXSW shows are all relatively low-stakes shows as you know. We've got this. We're a team, and I will do everything in my power to be the best, supportive partner I can be, just like you've been during these weeks of my plague.

You are not a fraud. There is nobody, NOBODY, I would rather share a stage with. Not IJG, not any of the big bands we've played with, nobody. It is an honor to make music with you, and I think you're a hell of a guitar player.

Plus you're really cute.

I love you endlessly.

(Apologies to everyone else for having to read this under-the-hood schmoop.)
Imposter Syndrome is frequent among people who Make Stuff Up (songs, poems, movies, plays, novels, legal briefs, scientific formulae, etc. etc. etc.) . The more innovative you are, the more you feel like, "what if this thing I'm making up is entirely false?"

Why do you think Truman Capote drank so much?


Just know that you are in good company. It's either a bug or a feature. I'm not entirely sure which. Know that at least you're smart enough to not completely see your work with rose-colored glasses, and know that Imposter Syndrome does happen to the best of us.

Seriously.

Neil Gaiman? Check. Sonia Sotomayor? Check. Albert Einstein? Yup.
And on and on and on. It's not just a sales trick to make some artists seem more human.
http://www.news.com.au/finance/highachievers-suffering-from-imposter-syndrome/story-e6frfm1i-1226779707766

Basically, just tell yourself, "there's that news van again," or whatever, when you feel it coming up. Tell yourself whatever you want. I usually say, "Oh, hi, it's you again, asshole," imagining a dirty black bird perching on my shoulder. and I yell shoo at it. IN MAH MIND.
Thank you for voicing this, Matt. I must echo what others have said above: clearly, sir, you are no fraud. Nor are you alone in the sensation that you may be. I am masquerading around in an adult costume, running a medical journal, pretending to be a writer (ha!), owning a home, driving around in car .... but oh, the talk in my head tells me that, any moment now, the Adulthood Police are going to find me out and take me away. We are all winging it in some way or another. Every night can't be your best night. But, even when you are a little off, you are so, so good. I've seen you guys play enough times to imagine I've witnessed performances where you may have felt fantastic, and others where you have felt not-so-great. But every show I've seen has been joyously entertaining. If you missed a note, no one noticed but Jill, and she still loves you.* Anyway, it's ok. You'll hit it next time. xo

*see schmooptastic comment above.
Also, FWIW: There may be a "it's that time of year" thing going on. March Madness, if you will. I think there's something in the collective subconscious that's reacting oddly to being at damn near 12 weeks of winter, plus 12 weeks of fall after that. I think everyone's feeling near a breaking point. you're not alone.
Yesterday I announced I would be giving a casual talk to my coworkers about How Secure Websites Work. The boss said, "can we record this one?" I said "sure!"

And then I started to panic as I realized it's been over 20 years since I touched the math involved. Or, like, touched math.

This was ridiculous. Although I am certainly not a mathematician, I am a more than capable programmer and an expert communicator. There was no way I wasn't gonna come up with an awesome little talk by morning.

And now I'm kinda pissed we didn't record it after all.
So...how DO secure websites work? Violence?
Cats in Stormtrooper helmets. They're called Stormpoopers.
I think some Philadelian had this idea a few years ago (was it Lindsay? Was it Tom? Was it Shelle? Was it MattL? Was it me? I don't even know, sweartagahd) that we should have a monthly/quarterly Philadel Salon-- where we Philadels get together and a few people get scheduled on an evening to give a 30-minute talk/presentation/activity on anything they want. If Lindsay has a play she's working on, we can take 30 mins to hear her explain it for 10 and us to read for 10 and discuss for 10. If Tom wants to teach us how Secure Websites Work, we'd love to learn about it. If MattL wants to show everyone how to draw rippling biceps, rock and roll! If MattC has a new song he wants to introduce, or Shelle has a new passage she wrote, whip it out!

It'd be a neat way for us to learn new stuff, both on the giving and receiving end.

We're all probably too busy to do this, but I think it'd be fun.
I think we talked about this, but space was a consideration. It was more of a "I have a skill which you might want to learn," so having Bobbi teach improv games, or Jenn or Tom teach dance, were things on the menu. so it was something which required space.

Your idea, though, of sharing the thing on which one is working, might require less space. or space could depend on activity. or something.
Always liked this idea.